| Easiest Five Selection |
| Darrell Whitford | Ohio State |
| Steve Wilken | Ohio State | |
| Toughest Five Selection |
| Aleks Nakutis |
| Andrew Reynolds |
| Andy Nemecek |
| Brad Duff |
| Brad Wilson |
| Chad Gumm |
| Chris Wanned |
| Dave Berrong |
| David Cords |
| David Synychak |
| Jeffery Murowsky |
| Joby Hapgood |
| Kevin Cheek |
| Michael Flanagan |
| Michael Lytle |
| Nathan Susanto |
| Robert Flatt |
| Skip Wilson |
| Tom Vobejda |
| Tyson Hester |
|
Selected 2 times. |
Selected 20 times. |
