| Easiest Five Selection |
| Kevin Cheek | Oklahoma |
| Kevin Whorton | Oklahoma |
| Mark Boggs | Stanford |
| Robert Flatt | Oklahoma | |
| Toughest Five Selection |
| Alan Simons Jr. |
| Andrew Maher |
| Brian Secord |
| Bryan Crouch |
| Christian Giovannetti |
| Dave Brooke |
| David Synychak |
| Ed Peck |
| Eric Franckowiak |
| Greg Krause |
| Jeff Mazurek |
| John Duffill |
| Matthew Hardman |
| Nate Morse |
| Nicholas Alicea |
| Robert Casares |
| Russ Goatcher |
| Shawn Temple |
| Tom Buske |
| Tyson Hester |
|
Selected 4 times. |
Selected 20 times. |
